Change
in the Air - Full transcript
"The fossilised remains
of prehistoric forests have been fought over, pumped and mined throughout the twentieth century.
Fossil fuels have
powered the industrial revolution
across the globe. But the burning of coal, oil and gas to provide electricity for our homes and
factories and fuel
for our cars, trains and aeroplanes
has fuelled another fire. It has led to an increased greenhouse effect, a suspected global rise in
the earths
temperature, and changed the
climate of many parts of the world.
"Over More than 80% of the primary greenhouse gas CO2, released into the atmosphere due to human
activity, comes
from burning fossil fuels.
"Today, just one country releases almost a quarter of global greenhouse gas emissions.
"The United States releases more than four times the global average of greenhouse gas emissions per
head of the
population, more than 20
tons per person per year, compared to under less than 10 in the UK and just 2.7 in China, that's 22%
of the worlds
greenhouses gasses from a
country with little more than 4% of the worlds population."
EARTH REPORT TITLE: "Change in the Air"
VOX POP 1: "Sea levels are rising, beaches are eroding, we're on a classic collision course."
VOX POP 2: "Everything we've had is ruined, baby pictures, married pictures, everything is gone."
VOX POP 3: "We originally won a Nobel peace prize with concern for nuclear weapons, this is like
nuclear war in slow
motion."
COMM: "The United States is not immune from the effects of greenhouse gas emissions, climate change
has affected
every state.
"The Kyoto protocol aims to reduce emissions but the American government has failed to comply in the
face of
powerful opposition from the coal and oil
lobby. Unless the US signs up to Kyoto it is an all but worthless document. Unlike congress, public
opinion in the
US now seems to be moving in
favour of accepting limits to greenhouse gas emissions. One reason is this - the US National
Assessment Report.
Sober, thorough, undramatic, it
dishes the tobacco scientists .in the pay of the fossil fuel interests - it shows that North America is
already in
the grip of potentially catastrophic
climate change.
This week we report on just a few of the national assesement findings."
SUB-TITLE: ALASKA
COMM: "With an area of over 580 thousand square milesmore than 1.5 million square kilometres, Alaska
is bigger than
the next three of the largest US
states combined. It has 3 million lakes, 5,000 glaciers and 17 of the highest 20 mountains in the US.
Yet its
scale does not protect it from global forces. 1.23 million acres hectares of spruce spine forest are
diseased and
dying, in some areas over more than
90% are dead.
"Ed Holsten is as forest entimologist. He has been working in Alaska for over more than 22 years.
"The spruce pine tree is the most predominant of only three species of tree that flourish in this
northern region
where cold harsh winters tend to
discourage both plant and animal species not adapted to these latitudes."
ED HOLSTEN: "Every year we fly around forested areas in Alaska, mapping in insect and disease damage.
A lot of the
times you fly over a mixed forest
and you look down you'll see maybe five or ten trees per acre killed and a lot of hardwood trees.
Then all of a
sudden you get into another area where
you have pure spruce come over a little knoll and as far as you can see for 20 miles there will be a
sea of red
brown trees and maybe one percent will
be green trees. Without being in an aeroplane and seeing this it's hard to describe you can fly for
mile after mile
after mile and not see a green
tree."
COMM: "Ecologists studying the causes of this widespread destruction have pointed the finger at the
bark beetle. A
beetle normally associated with
killing spruce pine trees in warmer southerly latitudes, but where greater tree diversity has tended
to limit its
impact."
ED HOLSTEN: "This area here, this tree was killed a couple of years ago by beetles but by removing the
bark we can
see a couple of things that is very
indicative of Spruce Beetle. Number one all that live flome tissue is gone and all we're left with is
this boring
dust and this is just the remains of
where the beetles have been feeding. They've consumed all the flome tissue. But this gallery right
here which is
about 3-4 inches long is called the
egg gallery and it's about this long and then they lay up to 80 eggs on each side of this gallery,
will hatch out
perpendicular to the egg gallery and
will feed out in this direction and this direction. And so you'll have thousands of galleries all up
and down a
tree to a height of 20ft tall and
there is only one insect up here that makes an egg gallery like that and thats the Spruce Beetle. So
it's fairly
easy to determine that this was a
beetle killed tree."
COMM: "At the University of Alaska, Fairbanks, Climatologists have been charting a changing climate in
the region,
most clearly portrayed by a steady
trend of rising winter temperatures."
GUNTER WELLER: "There is a fairly consistent trend in the temperatures. An upward trend that makes
the temperature
warmer from year to year to year
and associated with that is the decrease in ice cover, melting of glaciers, thawing of permafrost,
and all these
signal very clearly that we have a
trend that continues to get worse from year to year and if you believe the computer models that have
been set up to
predict what is going to happen in
100 years time if they are correct and they seem to be born out by present observations, then it's
going to get
considerably worse."
ED HOSTEN: "In the last ten years we have lost more trees than we have in the previous 60 years, a
factor of 10
times more, and if you relate that tree
mortality then you plot out temperature, you can see in the last 10 years where we had a real
significant increase
in mean annual temperature that
corresponded to this explosive epidemic of Bark Beetle occurring in Alaska. We have not seen such a
long length of
favourable weather like this for
hundreds if not thousands of years and the Bark Beetle that normally has a two year life cycle many
years now goes
through it's life cycle in one year
which means we double the population every year and this has been occurring more and more and more in
recent years
and is one of the main factors for
creating these extensive Bark Beetle outbreaks that as far as we've known the intensity of the
outbreak is probably
unprecedented."
COMM: "The forest destruction has also impacted the human population. Robert Purcell is the local
fire chief in
Homer, a town on the northern tip of
the Kenai peninsular."
ROBERT PURCELL: "The Bark Beetle poses a threat from the trees to homes and people here often chose to
keep the
trees as close to their homes as
possible. There was a very real concerted effort to preserve the forest as people built in this
forest and to
suddenly find that the forest is a
threat either by the trees falling on the homes in a windstorm as they die or potentially catching
fire if we have a
major fire, and we have had fire
events here that have threatened homes, has changed the perspective into a degree where the forest was
seen as sort
of warm and embracing or
sheltering, there's a component of threat now.
"I see a similarity between the Spruce Bark Beetle infestation and the impacts that came from the
Exxon Valdez oil
spill. It's challenged the
economies of communities, it's challenged peoples values, it's made people deal with an issue that
they probably
hadn't anticipated they would need to
or have to deal with. I think there's a very important human dimension to something of this scale
that isn't really
acknowledged as maybe as much as
it should, and thats something that has surprised me that there hasn't been more study and thought
associated with
that. The interaction of the human
experience and this kind of disturbance in the forest."
ED HOLSTEN: "Many areas that have been impacted by beetles there is no Spruce regeneration coming back
and we are
seeing a conversion of a Spruce
forest to grass and brush and hardwood. We are changing the eco system, the structure and the
composition of the
forest in many parts of Alaska are
changing due to a beetle that has changed its behaviour due to increase in temperature."
COMM: "A warming climate may benefit many varieties of insect and other pests, it does not help
preserve the worlds
ice sheets. These frozen wastes
have a far greater significance to our oceans, our climate, to fish and animal life, than there remote
location
might suggest."
SUB-TITLE: MONTANA
COMM: "In the North Mid-West of the United States lies the state of Montana. Outside Alaska it
contains one of the
largest areas of undisturbed
wilderness in the United States and some of the most southrly glaciers to be found on the continent.
Glacier
National Park makes up the majority of
this area."
DAN FAGRE: "Big natural parks like this are extremely unique. We have 5,000 sq kms or 1600 sq miles
here and it's
relatively pristine. Very few
effects of people are here so in this way we are able to use a very unique situation in this grand
national park to
be able to learn about how systems
really operate."
COMM: "Dr Fagre is using the park to study glaciers. Across the globe at extreme latitudes and
elevations there has
been a consistent and measurable
amount of ice melt and glacial retreat in recent years. It has been estimated that half the worlds
glaciers have
already been lost. In Montana,
Glacier National Park has not escaped these losses."
DAN FAGRE: "Glaciers used to be much more dominant here and in 1850 there were about 150 glaciers here
and now there
are less than 37 of them that are
named and we suspect that there is probably some of them that don't even qualify as glaciers anymore
because they've
become so small."
COMM: "The apparent speed of the retreat of the normally slow moving glaciers has spurred Dr. Fagre
into mapping
just how fast and how serious the
glacial loss is, and to find the extent this could be related to climate."
DAN FAGRE: "One of the activities that we've had here at the glacier field station with the US
Geological Survey is
to look at how this eco system has
already responded to climate change. As part of that effort we've been looking at many of the
glaciers and they way
they have receded over the past
150 years. To demonstrate some of this we've been looking at repeat photography in this case we go to
the historic
archives and we take a photo like
this one from 1932 of the Boulder Glacier, note the small figures here, these are people standing next
to this huge
ice cave, and then you go to the
exact same photo point and 56 years later you see there is absolutely no ice left whatsoever in the
landscape. The
entire glacier has disappeared and
that was quite a large one. And by repeating this for many of the glaciers in the park we've been
able to show that
most of the glaciers have
disappeared and even the ones that remain are a mere fraction of their previous size. And this is a
graphic and
dramatic example of the kinds of
ecological changes that are going on here at Glacier National Park in Montana. You can see
historically here from
this graph too that the area of the
glaciers from 1850 into the early part of this century and you can that they go down dramatically as
this lower line
which is the average summer
temperature goes up. And so this clearly demonstrates that the glaciers are responding to warming
temperatures in
this particular area this century.
"One of the tools we've been using to try to see what the future would be like for Glacier National
Park is Eco
System Modelling. So in this
particular sequence we've actually used data from the past, from 1850 up to the present and then
extrapolated that
into the future and in this
particular scenario you can see that all of our glaciers disappear by the year 2030. If you look
closely here you
will see that the vegetation is also
changing behind the glacial recession so one of the significant features is that grasses move into
some of the areas
that were previously forested. So
the mix of vegetation and the disappearance of glaciers in Glacier National Park will give us a very
different look
into the future.
"We can be assured that climate is the main driver because we have no other kinds of influences
regionally or
locally that would affect the kinds of
eco system responses that we're seeing. That's one of the beauties of using a National Park to try to
figure out
what's making these ecosystems tick.
Most of the other influences are greatly diminished or gone all together so we can attribute things
like glacier
recession and vegetation change
primarily to climatic change and external things of this sort. So we feel fairly confident that these
glaciers have
retreated because the climate has
shifted over the last 150 years."
COMM: "Scientists predict the impact of ice melt and glacier loss will not be restricted to the colder
regions, but
will be felt across the globe."
GUNTER WELLER: "As glaciers continue to melt, this will have a major impact on the global sea level
rise and sea
level rise is a problem in many parts
of the world - low lying areas, that is why the Pacific island nations are so concerned.
"You know various studies have shown that the sea level rise which is estimated to be about 20cm over
the last
century - 2mm per year has been mostly
due to, half of it has been due to melting of mountain glaciers. Also as you have more open water
instead of ice,
climate patterns begin to change,
storm tracks which are affected by the presence or absence of ice will change and therefore the
weather as well as
the climate in certain parts will be
affected, the ocean is extremely important in all of this and any changes that occur in the oceans
system will
affect everything else."
COMM: "In part two we see how changing climate is impacting the temperate and tropical areas of the
US."
SUB-TITLE: "THE EASTERN SEABOARD
COMM: "The impact of global warming on the worlds oceans is already having a significant effect on the
coastal areas
of the United States. Court
Stevenson, a professor of environmental science at Maryland University and has been monitoring sea
level rise on the
Chesapeake Bay area. He plans to
visit James' Island off the western shore."
PROF. COURT STEVENSON, MARYLAND UNIVERSITY: "I don't think myself I expected the kind of rise in the
1990's that
we're seeing on the gauges at all. I
would have expected to see a change from 3mm to 6mm but now we have 1.6 cm which is considerably
more than I would
have ever predicted in the 1980's,
so we've got much more than 10 times the original sea level rate."
WE SEE COURT ON A BOAT IN THE BAY: "See the surf out there eating away at that?
"I used to navigate in here 10 years ago, using that as a forest stand, it was a big clump of forest,
now you can
hardly make it out.
"In the 1940's it was split into two islands, each about 200 acres but now its less than 60 acres."
COURT STEVENSON: "If the trees are lost and the island disappears and it turns into a shoal the waves
will be
dissipated onto a number of homeowners
beaches and we'll start to see the erosion of the mainland itself."
COMM: "Homeowners are finding that as the barrier islands disappear, land on the mainland is being
lost at an ever
increasing rate."
JOE COIN Resident Homeowner: "Many many homes have been lost many many homes have been moved from
islands that are
sinking into the Chesapeake bay onto
firmer ground on the mainland and now even some of those homes are now in jeopardy, having been moved
once they find
themselves in jeopardy once
again."
COMM (beaches Florida): "Further south, the state of Florida is also suffering from severe and
increasing rates of
coastal erosion."
Dr. LEATHERMAN: "Well at high tide I'd be under water and the waves would be bashing into me, this
area is a
critically eroding area, like much of the
coastline of Florida that's eroding, in fact in the United States 80% to 90% of beaches are presently
eroding, it's
a national problem."
COMM (beaches): "It's a problem exacerbated by a long term trend towards shore ward migration of the
population.
Some xx% of all Americans now live on
the coast compared to just xx% of the population xx years ago."
Dr. Leatherman: "Americans have a love affair with beaches, there is a shore ward migration of the
population, and
at the same time sea level is
rising, beaches are eroding, we're on a classic collision course."
COMM (wind hotels, offices): "A collision that is surely felt most directly during the many storms and
hurricanes
that lash this coastline, putting at
risk not only lives but the whole infrastructure that has been put in place to serve the rising
population."
Dr. Leatherman: "Some of our most valuable real estate is packed along the coastline, in fact along
the US eastern
gulf coast it's estimated that there
are 3.1 trillion, with a T, trillion dollars in real estate vulnerable to beach erosion and hurricane
impacts."
COMM (flood footage, Hurricane Centre): "While coastal erosion from sea level rise is a relatively
slow albeit
unstoppable force, damage from flood and
storm is far more immediate but no less related to the influence of global warming. During Hurricane
Irene, a
relatively minor force 1 hurricane, much
of downtown Miami was under water Climate models predict that as the earth warms hurricane winds may
not become any
more frequent, but they will
increase in intensity and appear over a wider area, even as far north as Chesapeake Bay."
Court Stevenson: "If we have a little bit more warming and the isotherms, the levels of temperature
are shifted
northwards in the ocean before the
hurricane comes in if its getting much warmer water the wind forces stay very high. If we have a 4 or
5 category
hurricane as Camille hit in 1969 down
in the gulf coast we would have a tragedy beyond anything we've experienced in Chesapeake bay."
COMM: "Hurricane Andrew that hit xxx Florida and Louisiana in 19xx 1992 was a force 4/5 (?)
hurricaneCategory 4
storm with wind speeds of more than 250
km an hour."
Dr. Leatherman: "Andrew was the worst natural disaster economically in the world, at 30 billion
dollars, I don't
think there's anything that comes
close to that."
COMM (flood aftermath damage in South Carolina): "Tracked by the National Hurricane Centre in Miami,
the largest
hurricane in the 1999 season was
Floyd. At one time it was predicted it would hit Florida, in the panic to escape major freeways were
blocked solid
for 24 hours trapping some 6 (?)
million people. At the eleventh hour it veered northwards dissipated somewhat as it hit cooler water
and made
landfall in North Carolina.
"The greater percentage of damage that stems from Hurricane winds is not usually from the wind itself
but from the
accompanying surge in tides and
excessive rainfall.."
LADY WITH CONDEMNED HOUSE: "You can see the line here where it got into my house, and this is not a
pretty sight,
everything we had on the porch
washed, and this is where I did most of my living because it's cool out here, every things gone. I had
an old player
piano over there and its washed
away.
"Here I had five dead cows floating, the water was all the way up and they were floating right out
here and the
stench is better, but it's still bad.
And every time I come I look for my kitty cat and I can't find my cat so...(cries)"
MAN HOMEOWNER: "We've been married for 42 years, everything we've had is ruined, baby pictures, family
pictures,
everything is gone."
ANOTHER MAN HOMEOWNER: "When I opened the door, pulled the door open, the refrigerator floated right
to me, the
refrigerator, everything, table, stove,
it just floated right to you, and floated right on down the street with you, that's how high it
was."
COMM (Fema HQ): "Although hurricane Floyd caused far less damage than it would had it hit Florida the
week before,
it was never the less highly
destructive."
FEMA SPOKESPERSON: "Fema has 600 people working 7 days a week on this disaster, we have 57,000
requests for
assistance FEMA will end up reimbursing the
state of North Carolina for all this in the high single billions of dollars."
COMM: "The combination of increased storms and floods with sea level rise could well make disasters
like Floyd a
regular occurrence for people living
in coastal zones."
ENDING: "There are solutions, - increasing the efficiency with which we use energy, wasting less,
travelling less,
using renewable energy sources from
the wind, the sun and waves which do not release global warming gasses such as CO2 into the
atmosphere. In many
cases they There are many real
economic alternatives to that would make us less dependent on fossil fuel power stations."
WWF PERSON: "We can see now that the effects of global warming and climate change will affect us all,
the climate
respects no boundaries. But it's not
too late to do something about our climate. The US has to implement measures that will reduce CO2
emissions into
our atmosphere, but it must act now."
For more on
climate
change, search OneWorld.net:
(simply add
extra keywords
- separated with commas - and press
search).